Reviews are something an owner turns on (#11666)

A green pull in an app whose owner has not asked for reviews, and where no reviewer is seated, lands by itself. No review is sent and nothing waits for one.

This changes the default. Before, a green agent pull with no reviewer seated waited for a person forever. Now, with Require review off (the default) and no reviewer on the crew, it lands once its check passes. A new forge's first app has reviews off, so its first change goes live on green. An owner who wants a second look before anything lands turns reviews on, as below.

How to turn reviews on

Either one keeps every agent pull waiting for an approving review:

What still stops a pull with reviews off

A conflict, a red check, a hold, the access wall, and a changes requested verdict on the head. Only the wait for a review is gone. The pull's page, the terminal and the MCP pull tool read "Next: queue, green, reviews are off: it lands".

One rule

reviewsOff in src/crew/review.ts: requireReview is off and no reviewer is seated. The gate (reviewed), the review waits (reviewWaitsFor) and the next-actor line (nextAsking, used by nextOfPull and stepsOfStored) all ask it, so they cannot drift.

Cost

The seated reviewers are read only when the answer would otherwise be "waiting for the reviewer", and only when Require review is off: at most once per pull page, at most once per batch of pulls. The pull page loads no crew otherwise, so its budget in test/pages-budget.test.ts is one higher for that read; the batch's is unchanged.

↑↓ navigate ↵ open ⌘↵ its app esc close

Keyboard shortcuts

Docs